|
Post by ringmasterrob on Jul 2, 2004 7:10:50 GMT
I think the scores at the moment are pretty fair actually, they offer a good reflection on the quality of of each article.
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Jul 22, 2004 9:24:14 GMT
I know it's only been up for one night but I have read this article prior to it going up and I have to give devolution a clear ***** for its detail, information and In my mind it is without a doubt the best article present.
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Sept 24, 2004 7:21:49 GMT
Article Ratings For The Latest update then? Mine are;
Roman Yoke: *****, because of the gravity of the points and the huge amount of facts and information in it. Another cracking good article HStorm!
BNP Mannyfesto: ***, funny but a little bit short really.
You can also rate the obituary if you like, but as I don't know who the author was (it was a chain email sent to my parents that was actually funny) then I won't be able to pass comments on.
|
|
|
Post by HStorm on Sept 25, 2004 0:04:33 GMT
Thanks Rob!
I give the mannyfesto an unreserved *****
The obituary seems a little like satire plucked from 2000, with strong overtones of William Hague's ill-fated 'common sense revolution'. It's amusing but maybe feels just a bit like last week's news. (Although let's face it, my last couple of articles have been about stuff that's centuries old, so it's hardly a serious problem!) ***
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Oct 13, 2004 14:21:53 GMT
The more observant of you will have noticed I have updated the ratings on the Articles page, adding in the '****' the second Arab-Israeli Essay written by Critique was given (its only rating to date) as well as the ratings for the latest articles so far, if anyone has a rating to add then the ratings for the latest articles will change, the ratings are based on averages.
(e.g. BNP Mannyfesto
one review of *** and one of ***** gives a score of ****)
I have also removed a few non-article rating posts from earlier in the topic as they were irrelvant and traces of pointless bickering, if anyone's post count has dropped due to this I apologise. Remember the topic is purely for ratings, nothing else, especially not bickering. One final point, the Arab Israel Essay 1 by Critique & Arab-Israeli Conflict: Problems With Peace by Me both need ratings, if anyone has them to offer.
[EDIT: Typo corrected (you smart arse!)]
|
|
|
Post by Naselus on Oct 13, 2004 14:24:01 GMT
Should be **** in your example mate. But I'm sure that was a typo.
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Nov 3, 2004 8:15:55 GMT
There are several new articles for your reviewing pleasure, some of which aren't actually written by those who sent them in so they don't have to be rated unless chosen to. I'm in a good mood so mine are all ridiculously high because I enjoyed the articles: WORSE THAN SADDAM: ***** (really gets the point across on this issues) BUSH WAR SYNDROME: ***** (hilarious stuff, made me laugh out loud reading it) BEST HEADLINES: ***** (as Bush War, made me laugh out loud reading it) REPUBLICANS: ***** (I think I may know a few Republicans from the last line of the articles )
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Dec 15, 2004 12:32:40 GMT
For the latest, in a series of HStorm's articles, then I feel it is just as good. It's nice to see how flexible your writing is and that you can defend a point of view contrary to your own so interestingly. A good read:
****
|
|
|
Post by loremastermiar on Dec 15, 2004 12:49:46 GMT
Glad to see you enjoyed the Republicans.
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Dec 15, 2004 14:26:06 GMT
Indeed I did, on a side note then I seem to be the only one who has reviewed the latest articles on the site. On that vibe I have put my ratings on the main site for the moment, if anyone else wishes to add ratings then I will alter those there at the moment to the average. Also there are the 2 new articles to be reviewed. Happy reviewing...
|
|
|
Post by Naselus on Dec 15, 2004 16:25:20 GMT
four stars each. Both informative, entertaining and well written.
|
|
|
Post by HStorm on Dec 15, 2004 17:41:16 GMT
For it's exhaustive research, engrossing style and detailed insight (it taught me a few bits and bobs I'd never heard before!) I give Rob's Bane Of Ukraine (oh yes, clever title as well, before I forget) an unreserved * * * * *. Yes, five stars. A mix of tremendous effort, research (kindly take note of that key point please, Oliver...), shrewd deduction and a healthily skeptical interpretation. One of the finest articles so far.
Oh, apologies to Ruzl and LMM for forgetting to offer ratings for their articles from last month. Here goes...
Republicans..... * * * *
Bush War Syndrome..... * * * * *
|
|
|
Post by ringmasterrob on Feb 4, 2005 16:08:11 GMT
As the new ratings system has been introduced, this topic is now defunct. Locked!
|
|